Authenticity and Honesty as an Indie Author by @JoRobinson176

A couple of things we shouldn’t be doing. Sometimes you’ll see an author comparing their writing to a famous writer in the actual blurb of their book, or worse still on the cover. Doing this in a blurb is actually against Amazon policy, so it’s not a good idea to begin with. Some Indies seem to think that by the mere presence of a bestselling author’s name, readers will be more inclined to buy their own book. Speaking as a reader all I can say about that is that if I want to read a book by J K Rowling I’ll buy one of her books. If a reader or reviewer on the other hand compares a book to the work of a famous author I’m a fan of, I might be tempted to buy it – that to me is a genuine compliment, but if it’s the author making the comparison it always comes across as a little desperate to me.

Desperation doesn’t sell well, and readers aren’t stupid. We prefer authenticity in the books we read. Why on Earth would any writer want to hang on to another writer’s coattails? I’ve heard that copying famous writer’s styles can be a good writing exercise, although I’ve never tried it myself. I’d much rather stick to my own style, whatever that may be, than to try and sell anything on the back of someone else’s success. Every time a book makes it big there are suddenly thousands of copycat versions dumped onto the market, and none of them will ever have the impact of the original. Every writer has their own unique writing voice, and we should always be true to that – even when we’re selling our wares.

Another thing I’ve seen is #1 BESTSELLER plastered on the cover of a book. Then I’ve looked at the book’s ranking, and it’s at two million and odd. That’s not a bestseller and I don’t appreciate the attempt to con me. I’ve read several comments from Indie authors saying that it’s the truth because at some point their books have been number one on a free list. That’s just way beyond wrong so don’t do this. We’ve all been in the paid bestseller lists at some point or another, but if you honestly want to put that on your book it must have been number one on the main list, and if it reaches that beautiful spot everyone will already know what it is.

I always use the Look Inside feature on Amazon before I buy any book. A huge mistake some Indies make is to put pages and pages of reviews in their front matter. Often you haven’t got to the end of them before the preview ends. No book purchase from me in that case. I don’t have a problem with a few lines from good reviews on a single page, but more than that – yes – again seems desperate to me. Readers will read the book reviews anyway, both the good and the bad, so the reviews in the front matter aren’t going to mean anything except that they’re taking up too much space. The last thing about using reviews in your book is actually using them on your book. Fine for if the book has reviews from Kirkus or something like that, but putting one of the three reviews that the book has on your actual cover is not a good idea at all. The last time I saw this I cringed in shame on behalf of that author.

As self-published authors we have to act professionally, respect our readers, and credit them with the savvy to spot things like this. We should trust in our own authenticity and have the patience for it to be seen for what it is, and hopefully enjoyed for its own sake. Image1000

Author: jorobinson176

South African writer.

42 thoughts on “Authenticity and Honesty as an Indie Author by @JoRobinson176”

  1. Thanks for the advice, Jo. A speaker at a writer’s conference once told me I should compare my book to someone’s people would recognize – but I believe you! Also breathing easy – kept the comments on the previous book to one page. Whew!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks Noelle! I reckon that readers should be able to see from the blurb and genre alone if a book is something they want to read and that comparing a book to a specific author is bad from the perspective that it gives the impression that you’re trying to write like them. Of all my favourite authors in the same genre, no two of them write alike. 🙂


    1. Thanks Natacha! I’ve seen so many books that looked a bit meh from some of the reviews, but then looking inside swayed me, and I bought them on the strength of that. Look Inside is a much bigger selling tool that we give it credit for.


  2. desperation dose sell, look at the world we live, and we all say we love by the way o desperation, look at all the death and people say they can make a better world, flawed world at its best


  3. Great advice! I totally agree . . . now on the flip-side, I’ve had reviewers constantly compare the “spirit” of my book to Monty Python. So I let people know if they’re a fan of such things they would probably like this, but I’d rather have the book discovered for its own unique qualities. So, I’m a little torn on whether or not to make that comparison.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. Thank you. I tend to use Monty Python memes to advertise it indirectly. Trying to make ads fun for my followers, not spammy. Such a fine balance. But yeah, my reviewers started it. lol


      1. I have to admit it, it is. Being compared to Terry Pratchett would be better . . . but kind of glad not. It’s nice getting praised for my own unique voice.


  4. I enjoy reading these “Things You Shouldn’t Do” type of posts and realize that I don’t do them. It confirms I’m heading in the right direction. Thank!


  5. i’ve read in several writing manuals that editors/publishers want to know what other books already on the market are most like yours, and how yours is different. So I’m guessing it may be important to compare in that sense in your query/marketing strategy sent to the agent/publisher but definitely not with the reader/book reviewer,/marketing people. Is this correct?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: